India's successful long-range missile test vs. N. Korea's failed one


India says long-range missile test was a success
From Harmeet Shah Singh, CNN, Thu April 19, 2012

India said Thursday that it had successfully carried out the maiden test flight of its longest-range nuclear-capable missile, which can apparently travel more than 5,000 kilometers.

The Agni V rocket took off around 8:03 a.m. local time (10.33 p.m. Wednesday ET) and "met all the mission objectives," said S.P. Das, director of the missile test site.

The missile, whose stated range of about 3,100 miles puts major Chinese cities within its striking distance, was fired from the coast of the eastern Indian state of Orissa.

In November, India successfully tested the fourth version of Agni, meaning "fire" in Hindi, with a range of 3,500 km. Built years earlier, Agni I could travel 700 km, according to Indian defense authorities.

India borders two nuclear-armed states -- its arch-rival Pakistan; and China, with which it fought a brief but bitter war in 1962.

Currently, the five permanent member nations of the U.N. Security Council -- the United States, China, Russia, Britain and France -- are thought to have developed such technology,

India buys a lot of arms from overseas. It has overtaken China as the world's biggest importer of weapons, according to a recent report by the the Stockholm International Peace Research Institute


Apr 20, 2012
I am Tom Gjelten of NPR sitting in for Diane Rehm. Diane. Joining us for the international hour of the "Friday News Roundup," Michael Hirsh of National Journal, Courtney Kube of NBC and Abderrahim Foukara of Al Jazeera Arabic.

GJELTEN
India also test-launched a long-range missile this week. It was just announced yesterday. The missile that India tested is capable of carrying a nuclear weapon anywhere in China. It is interesting that we had such a reaction, a strong reaction to the North Korean test and almost nothing about the India missile test.

HIRSH
a very mild reaction from the U.S. basically saying, that India has done fairly well with non-proliferation.
This is part of this growing effort to build a strategic partnership with India vis-à-vis China.
The U.S., the Obama administration over the last couple of years has been engaged in a policy of encirclement where we're even making friends with Myanmar now as part of the policy of putting pressure on Beijing
So there tends to be a supportive effort toward India which we see as a future ally in at least putting geo-political pressure on China. So that's why there's something of a mild reaction to that.

GJELTEN
the United States is really anxious to develop strong relations with India. On the other hand, India has not been very supportive of the United States in its effort to isolate Iran. India is continuing among all the big buyers of Iranian oil.  India has not been willing to go along with the sanctions that the United States is proposing. Courtney.

KUBE
the immediate condemnation of the North Korean launch last week that was in the air for 80 seconds or something and then crashed into the Yellow Sea and did nothing
But then when India launches a long-range intercontinental ballistic missile capable of carrying a one and a half ton nuclear warhead...
it launched and 20 minutes later, it was declared successful.
And the United States, the reaction was, India is defensive. And they have a no strike first policy so we're okay with this, which is pretty remarkable, a week later, the difference.

GJELTEN
Well, the head of India's defense research and development organization said this test-firing shows that India has emerged from this launch as a major missile power.

FOUKARA
India plays on so many different ropes. In some cases, it supports the United States. In some other cases, it doesn't.
On the issue of Iran, India obviously sees itself as part of the brick bloc, which includes countries such as Russia, South Africa, Turkey and Brazil and these countries do not look too favorably on being hostile to Iran by the United States and Israel.
But if I may circle this back to Afghanistan ... because it always circles back to Afghanistan in one way or another.
Afghanistan is an influence battleground between Pakistan and India.  Pakistan sees China as an ally, a potential ally against India.  Therefore, China is very relevant to what happens in Afghanistan and to any future settlements between Pakistan and India, and therefore, any future settlements between the United States and the Taliban.  Have I made it any less complicated?

HIRSH
China's point of view is Afghanistan is not that terribly important. It's a little bit mystifying here, where you don't have any sort of really keen ideological difference between India and Pakistan.  They so regard each other as partners.  China came out in its response to the missile launch and said, we see it more of a partner.  This is not the cold war, we're not the U.S. and the Soviet Union and it's a little unclear why this arms race is going on